Renting a Car in Key West: Excess, Deposit and Counter Extras
5 min read
Short answer. Compare the final price, not the daily headline. A Key West rental quote can change through the excess attached to CDW, the security deposit blocked on a card, a one-way fee for returning in Miami, additional-driver or young-driver charges, fuel and local taxes. None of those figures is universal. Compare Key West rentals on Discover Cars, open the rental conditions for the exact car, and save them before you pay.
Excess and deposit are different
CDW limits what the rental company may charge for covered damage, but it can still leave an excess. That is the amount for which you may remain responsible under the contract. “Full protection” sold by a comparison site may reimburse covered costs after you provide documents; it is not automatically the same product as the rental company’s zero-excess cover.
The deposit is a temporary card authorisation used as security. It is not a purchase and it is not proof that your excess has disappeared. Its amount, acceptable cards and release time depend on the supplier and rate. Check all three in the rental conditions. Do not invent a comfortable number in your budget: a deposit that is larger than your available card limit can stop collection at the desk.
What to check before payment
- Payment card: whose name must be on it, whether debit cards are accepted, and which card types are excluded.
- Fuel policy: full-to-full is easy to compare; prepaid fuel may leave you paying for fuel you do not use.
- Additional driver: check whether the quote includes one or charges per rental day.
- Age rules: minimum age and young-driver charges differ by supplier. Read the condition attached to your offer.
- One-way fee: collecting in Miami and returning in Key West can carry a separate charge. Compare the total, not two daily rates.
- Tolls: ask how the supplier handles electronic tolls before leaving Miami; do not assume the transponder is free.
Take timestamped photographs of every side, the wheels, glass, roof and fuel gauge at collection and return. Make sure existing marks are on the condition report before you drive away.
When buying extra cover is poor value
Do not buy a second product before you know what the first covers. Your card or travel insurance may offer rental protection, but exclusions, claim order and eligible vehicles vary. Read its wording and ask the issuer; the counter agent cannot interpret a policy issued by somebody else.
Conversely, declining every extra is not automatically cheaper if the remaining excess would be difficult to pay. The honest comparison is the total rental cost, the amount blocked, the remaining risk and the paperwork required after damage.
Do you need the car at all?
In Old Town, usually not. Parking can cost more than transport, and the sights are close together. Our car-free Key West guide explains the alternatives. The Old Town Trolley is €50.42, rated 4.6 from 500 reviews, and gives you 13 hop-on, hop-off stops without a deposit or parking bill.
See availability and prices for the Old Town Trolley
Our recommendation
If the car is for the Overseas Highway, compare the complete rental conditions and price a one-way return as a separate option. If you fly into Key West and sleep in Old Town, skip the rental and spend the difference on the water.